The character was a natural for television, and the three seasons of Spenser: For Hire, from 1985 to ’88, proved quite popular ... with everybody except Parker’s fans, and most notably Parker himself. The character’s surface trappings were retained, but the tone was wrong; Robert Urich was too young, too handsome, and much too swaggering. Spenser is quietly smug, not boldly cocky; he knows that he’s the toughest and smartest guy in the room, and has no reason to announce it. Although Parker was involved with the show as a “consultant,” he famously said — in a 1999 Los Angeles Times interview — “I read scripts and offered comments which no one paid attention to.”
Urich nonetheless reprised the role for a quartet of made-for-TV movies from 1993 to ’95; although each was based on one of Parker’s novels, the results still were disappointing. That said, they were akin to Citizen Kane, when compared to 2020’s Spenser Confidential, which must’ve had Parker spinning in his grave. Everything about that Netflix original is awful, starting with the badly miscast Mark Wahlberg, but most notably the production’s jokey, action/comedy tone. Sacrilege!
Ah, but in between — from 1999 to 2001 — cable’s A&E Network delivered a trio of films starring Joe Mantegna, who is note-perfect as Spenser. Co-star Marcia Gay Harden is equally fine as his longtime main squeeze, psychologist Susan Silverman. Parker exercised far more creative control over these three films — Small Vices, Thin Air and Walking Shadow — all of which are adapted from his novels; he scripted the first two, and co-scripted the third with his wife, Joan. Unfortunately, the parsimonious budgets compromised the results, particularly with the second and third films ... which cut short what A&E originally had intended as a five-film series. Small Vices, however, is a little gem; Parker’s fans must’ve been delighted to hear so much of the dialogue being lifted, word for word, from the source novel.
